Home Bar · Recipe units
When a Mocktail Recipe Says Top With, the Mixer Amount Is Still Open
Top with is an assembly step, not a universal number to multiply for a group.
A published base measure does not fill in an unstated sparkling pour
- 01Published2 fl oz Grove 42
Seedlip's base measure for one Grove Spritz
- 02UnmeasuredTonic or club soda
The source says top, with no mixer volume
- 03Your planLabel any assumption
A chosen pour is not a producer-published ratio
Ritual's separate Ranch Water says about 6 fl oz soda; that approximation belongs only to its own recipe
A recipe can be precise about the first two ounces and completely open about the last pour. Seedlip's US Grove Spritz measures 2 fl oz Grove 42, then says to top the glass with tonic water or club soda. Bundaberg's Mimic Mule gives a lime, mint and 10 ml sugar syrup, then says to top with its Ginger Beer. Neither page says how many ounces of the sparkling mixer go into the finished glass. That missing number matters when you are shopping for six, not just one.
“Top with” is an assembly instruction, not a hidden universal measure. Glass shape, ice, the first ingredients and how full the server chooses to pour all affect the space left. None of those details converts the producer's word into a reliable six-glass bottle count. The honest choice is to separate what the source actually measures from what the host must decide.
Three levels of information, not one ratio
| Recipe | Published base | Published sparkling instruction | What can be counted from the page |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seedlip Grove Spritz | 2 fl oz Grove 42 | Tonic water or club soda, “top” | Base for any chosen number of glasses; not the mixer volume |
| Bundaberg Mimic Mule | Lime, mint and 10 ml sugar syrup | Top with Bundaberg Ginger Beer | The named syrup per glass; not a number of glasses per Ginger Beer bottle |
| Ritual Ranch Water | 1½ fl oz Agave Alternative and ½ fl oz lime | About 6 fl oz soda water | An approximate soda-water plan, not a guaranteed final fill |
Ritual's “about 6 ounces” is not the same as an entirely unmeasured top-up. For six individual Ranch Waters, 6 × about 6 = about 36 fl oz of soda water is a transparent planning estimate. The word “about” stays attached to the result. It is not a guaranteed final volume or permission to rewrite Seedlip's and Bundaberg's recipes with the same six-ounce measure.
By contrast, six Grove Spritz glasses need 12 fl oz Grove 42 according to Seedlip's base measure. That tells you something useful about the specialty bottle. It tells you nothing exact about the combined amount of tonic or club soda. Choosing a 4-ounce topper per glass would be your serving assumption, not Seedlip's recipe. If you choose to plan that way, write the assumption beside the arithmetic so it cannot later masquerade as a published ratio.
A shopping method when the topper is missing
First, name the exact mixer. Seedlip offers tonic water or club soda in its Grove Spritz, and those are separate ingredients with potentially different labels; Bundaberg names its own Ginger Beer. “Something fizzy” is not a complete shopping line. Second, keep all measured base quantities in their published units. Third, decide the glass and ice you intend to use, then decide whether you can make a conditional allowance for the unmeasured top-up. If you have not chosen a vessel, do not present an exact mixer count.
For a gathering, keep the producer's sequence visible too. A sparkling top-up added at serving says nothing about how a finished pitcher will hold its carbonation for hours. Seedlip and Bundaberg describe individual drinks here; Ritual likewise describes a glass, not a prepared batch. Multiplying ingredient shopping quantities can be reasonable when each glass will be assembled separately. The source does not provide a pitcher method.
This distinction is useful even when you already own a bottle of mixer. A full bottle may feel reassuring, but an unopened package volume cannot answer how much will remain after several unmeasured tops. If the mixer is essential to the drink, leave room in the shopping plan for uncertainty, and check the package's own storage instructions before carrying leftovers into another event.
Keep the blank line visible
The best recipe notes have two columns: source measure and host's assumption. Write “2 fl oz Grove 42 per glass” in the first. Leave the tonic volume blank unless you have made a separate serving decision, and label that decision as yours. When the producer says “about,” keep the approximation. That small act of honesty makes the list more useful than a neat but invented ratio.
- Seedlip US, Grove Spritz
- Bundaberg US, Mimic Mule
- Ritual Zero Proof US, Ranch Water