Mocktails · Coconut and cinnamon
Coquito Without the Optional Rum
Goya already makes the rum optional. Keep the four milk-and-coconut products distinct, and leave room for chilling.

Leave the rum off the shopping list, not the rest of the recipe. Goya's US recipe “Coquito – The Authentic Puerto Rican Eggnog” gives that option explicitly. Its coconut drink still needs four separate milk-and-coconut products, vanilla and cinnamon; a single carton of coconut milk does not complete the basket.
This is a cold blender preparation with a chilling step, not a drink ready to serve as soon as the blender stops. Match the cans and measure the portion taken from the condensed milk before starting. One qualification belongs up front: vanilla extract remains in Goya's formula, so omitting rum does not establish a finished 0.0% ABV drink.
The source formula without its optional rum
In that specific Goya recipe, the rum is optional. Its other ingredients are listed below; Goya also publishes a different Coquito formula, so use the quantities from this recipe together. Can sizes are reproduced as printed by the source; the ounces printed on a package should not all be treated as liquid fluid ounces.
| Ingredient | Source quantity |
|---|---|
| Goya Evaporated Milk | Two 12 oz cans |
| Goya Cream of Coconut | One 15 oz can |
| Goya Coconut Milk | One 13.5 oz can |
| Goya Sweetened Condensed Milk | 1/2 cup |
| Vanilla extract | 1 teaspoon |
| Ground cinnamon | 1/2 teaspoon, plus optional finishing cinnamon |
The original's half-cup rum is optional and is not included here. Its method blends the chosen ingredients on high for one to two minutes, transfers the mixture to tightly closed glass bottles and refrigerates until well chilled. Before serving, stir or shake the bottle to recombine, then pour into small glasses. Cinnamon and a cinnamon stick are optional finishing touches.
Follow the blender's own capacity and liquid instructions. This article does not turn that appliance step into permission to fill a particular jar to its rim. The source does not identify a blender model or its usable working volume.
Four package names that belong on the list
The distinction between coconut milk and cream of coconut matters here. Goya describes its coconut milk as unsweetened, while its cream of coconut is a different product. The two appear on separate lines of the formula. Do not silently merge them into one larger quantity because both start with coconut.
The dairy cans need the same attention. Goya's evaporated milk ingredient information and its milk-and-sugar condensed product are not two names for the same can. One is used by the can in this recipe; the other is measured by the cup. Copying only “canned milk” into a shopping app makes an avoidable substitution more likely.
Buy the product size that matches the list where possible. If your store has another size, establish whether the package quantity is weight or liquid volume before converting. The nominal weight of a thick sweetened product is not a fill line on a liquid measuring cup. Nothing is gained by making a precise-looking total from incompatible units.
Half a cup is not the whole condensed-milk can
The condensed milk is the ingredient most likely to leave a remainder. Put a half-cup measure on the preparation list, not just a can opener. Having bought one can does not mean the recipe asks you to empty it.
Decide what will happen to the unused product before opening it. Its own handling directions apply; a storage rule for an unopened pantry can does not describe the remainder or the blended drink. If you do not have a credible second use, that is a reason to think about the purchase—not to pour the excess into the batch for convenience.
The same principle makes the basket easier to hand to someone else. Write the package quantity in one column and the amount used in another. It prevents a helper from reasonably assuming that every can on the counter is destined for the blender in full.
Without rum does not establish 0.0% ABV
Vanilla extract remains in the source formula. McCormick's US Pure Vanilla Extract, as one concrete example, lists alcohol among its ingredients. That is not proof of the composition of whichever extract you own, but it is enough to rule out treating the word vanilla as an alcohol-free guarantee.
There is no numeric finished-drink ABV established here. If a precise alcohol statement is essential to your purchase decision, this version does not supply it. Replacing the extract with a vanilla syrup would change the published ingredient and quantity relationship; this guide does not present that as a verified workaround.
Count the source servings without inventing a pour
Goya labels the recipe as seven servings but does not specify the volume of each. Nor does its serving label give a separate measured yield for the no-rum option. Keep the seven as the author's serving description, not a guarantee that the batch fills seven glasses to a particular line.
For hosting, write down the glass you intend to use and the pour you plan to offer. Until a credible finished volume is available, do not turn the source's can sizes into an exact bottle count or promised number of refills. A bottle-yield calculation needs both a usable volume and a chosen pour; one cannot stand in for the other.
The recipe's displayed five-minute total also should not become your entire occasion timeline: its method still tells you to chill the mixture, without assigning that step a duration. Plan for that unresolved interval instead of promising guests a cold glass five minutes after opening the cupboard.
Coquito can have a clear place on the menu without taking over it. Offer it as the specific coconut-and-dairy preparation on your card, keep water and another option available, and use the correct package names. The appeal of this route is a real source method with an optional ingredient already accounted for—not a shortcut through the rest of its shopping list.
- Goya US — Coquito – The Authentic Puerto Rican Eggnog and four named milk/coconut product pages
- McCormick US — Pure Vanilla Extract ingredients